March 8, 1911 (11th Parliament, 3rd Session)

LIB

Wilfrid Laurier (Prime Minister; President of the Privy Council)

Liberal

Sir WILFRID LAURIER.

All this is subject to parliamentary approval. And what we have done has been done again and again, and done by my hon. friend him-

self, although he has forgotten it in a moment when he is served by a treacherous memory. But he knows he did this very thing in 1893, which he now reproaches us for doing. But my hon. friend knows that they did this very thing in 1893 which he now reproaches us with doing. There was a treaty, not a secret arrangement, tout an actual treaty negotiated in secret toy Sir Charles Tupper with the French government, which was brought here and accepted by the whole Conservative party. So I say that it is childish to _ present such an argument at the present time in opposition to this agreement.
At six o'clock the House took recess.
After Recess.
House resumed at eight o'clock.
House divided on amendment-(Mr. Borden, Halifax).

Messieurs
Ames,
Arthurs,
Barker,
Barnard,
Beattie,
Best,
Blain,
Blondin,
Borden (Halifax), Boyce,
Bradbury,
Broder,.
Burrell,
Campbell,
Crocket,
Crotbers,
Currie (Simcoe), Daniel,
Donnelly,
Edwards,
Elson,
Foster,
Gilbert,
Goodeve,
H'aggart (Winnipeg), Harris,
Henderson,
Herron,
Hughes,
Jameson,
Kidd,
Lake,
Lalor,
Lancaster,
Lennox,
Lortie,
Macdonell,
Maclean (York, S.), McCall,
Maddin,
Marshall,
Medgben,
Middlebro,
Monk,
Nan tel,
Northrup,
Owen,
Paqnet,
Perley,
Porter,
Price,
Reid (Grenville), Roche,
Russell,
Schaffner,
Sexsmith,
Sharpe (Lisgar), Sharpe (Ontario), Sifton,
Stanfield,
Staples, !
Stewart,
Taylor (Leeds), Taylor
(New Westminster), Thoburn,
Thornton,
White (Renfrew), Wilcox,
Wilson Lennox & Addington) and Wright.-70.
Messieurs
Allard, McColl,
Allen, McCraney,
Aylesworth (Sir Allen) McIntyre, Beauparlant, McKenzie,
Beland, McLean (Huron),
Black, McLean (Suntoury),

Topic:   WAYS AND MEANS-RECIPROCAL TRADE WITH UNITED STATES.
Subtopic:   P. C. KNOX,
Full View