June 2, 1921

UNION

Charles Joseph Doherty (Minister of Justice and Attorney General of Canada)

Unionist

Mr. DOHERTY:

There still seems room for improvement.

Topic:   CRIMINAL CODE AMENDMENT BILL
Permalink
L LIB
UNION

Charles Joseph Doherty (Minister of Justice and Attorney General of Canada)

Unionist

Mr. DOHERTY:

It is characteristic of

some people to labour under false impressions.

The next amendment deals with section 12 whereby the burning of chattels was constituted a crime. The penalty is reduced from fourteen to five years' imprisonment, and the value prescribed for the article burned is raised from $25 to $200.

The next amendments consist in striking out articles 14 and 15. These are the clauses dealing with cruelty to animals, the first clause being directed against the docking of tails, and the other against cruelly killing.

The next amendment is of a constructive character and consists in introducing into the Bill section 24A adding what appears to be an omitted offence in the article of the Criminal Code proscribing prosecution for certain crimes and is in this form:

24a. Paragraph (a) of section 1140 of the said Act is amended by adding thereto the following sub-paragraph:

"(iv) Any offence relating to or arising out of the location of land which was paid for in whole or in part by scrip or was granted upon certificates issued to half breeds in connection with the extinguishment of Indian title."

There does not seem to be any good reason why the same proscription which applies to other offences should not apply to this, and I am disposed to accept the amendment.

Then there is one other amendment, which is also of a constructive character. It introduces a provision which was contained in a Bill passed by the Senate this session. It provides for a revision of sentences by the Court of Appeal for the province in which the conviction was had. I would have preferred to have this clause the subject of further examination and consideration before adopting it. The Senate, however, passed the measure. When the Bill came to this House I consulted with the attorneys general of all the provinces, and, with one exception, I think no objection was taken to the clause, and in some instances positive approval was expressed. In view of those circumstances, and recognizing that there is merit in the proposal, I am disposed to ask this House to concur in the amendment.

Topic:   CRIMINAL CODE AMENDMENT BILL
Permalink
L LIB
UNION

Charles Joseph Doherty (Minister of Justice and Attorney General of Canada)

Unionist

Mr. DOHERTY:

It provides for a revision by the Court of Appeal for the province in which the conviction was had of sentences in criminal cases. It does not provide an appeal proper from the conviction, but it does make it possible to submit to a Court of Appeal the question whether the sentence is either inadequate or too severe.

Topic:   CRIMINAL CODE AMENDMENT BILL
Permalink
L LIB
UNION

Charles Joseph Doherty (Minister of Justice and Attorney General of Canada)

Unionist

Mr. DOHERTY:

Yes.

Topic:   CRIMINAL CODE AMENDMENT BILL
Permalink

Motion agreed to, and amendments read the second time and concurred in.


IMMIGRATION ACT AMENDMENT

SENATE AMENDMENTS


On motion of Hon. J. A. Calder (Minister of Immigration and Colonization) the amendments made by the Senate to Bill No. 139 to amend the Immigration Act were read the second time and concurred in.


SALE AND INSPECTION OF ROOT VEGETABLES

UNION

Simon Fraser Tolmie (Minister of Agriculture)

Unionist

Hon. S. F. TOLMIE (Minister of Agriculture) :

I beg leave of the House, Mr. Speaker, to withdraw this resolution. Motion agreed to and Order discharged.

Topic:   SALE AND INSPECTION OF ROOT VEGETABLES
Permalink

INCOME TAX ACT AMENDMENT


On the motion of Sir Henry Drayton (Minister of Finance) Bill No. 221 to amend the Income Tax Act was read the second time and the House went into committee thereon, Mr. Boivin in the Chair. On section 1-penalty for failure to file returns:


LIB

William Lyon Mackenzie King (Leader of the Official Opposition)

Liberal

Mr. MACKENZIE KING:

Will the

minister explain the amendment?

Topic:   INCOME TAX ACT AMENDMENT
Permalink
CON

Henry Lumley Drayton (Secretary of State of Canada; Minister of Finance and Receiver General)

Conservative (1867-1942)

Sir HENRY DRAYTON:

At present

the penalty for failure to file return of income is 25 per cent of the tax payable; that is reduced to a penalty of 5 per cent of tax payable, with a maximum of $500. Every person failing to make a return under the other provisions of the section is subject to a penalty of $10 for each day of default, but it is provided that such penalty shall not exceed $50.

Topic:   INCOME TAX ACT AMENDMENT
Permalink
L LIB

Daniel Duncan McKenzie

Laurier Liberal

Mr. McKENZIE:

It seems to me that this penalizing principle is not sound. If a man fails to make a return as called for by the Act his offence is the same no matter whether the tax to which he is liable is $10 or $1,000. Why not fix a certain amount which will be applicable to all?

Topic:   INCOME TAX ACT AMENDMENT
Permalink
CON

Henry Lumley Drayton (Secretary of State of Canada; Minister of Finance and Receiver General)

Conservative (1867-1942)

Sir HENRY DRAYTON:

There is no doubt that the offence is the same in each case, though the result of the offence is not the same. We are adhering to the principle which is maintained throughout the whole Act, that of making the ratepayer with the lower income subject to the lower assessments. The man with the larger income and whose default seriously affects the public treasury pays the higher penalty.

Topic:   INCOME TAX ACT AMENDMENT
Permalink

Section agreed to. On section 2-penalty for short payment:


June 2, 1921